Closed-end funds can be a good fit for Caterpillar employees looking for higher yields and diversification in their Retirement accounts - but you need to weigh the potential for higher returns against the risks with the help of an experienced advisor like myself - Wesley Boudreaux - of the Retirement Group, 'he said.
'Caterpillar employees interested in closed-end funds should consider their investment goals and risk tolerance - consulting with a professional like Patrick Ray at The Retirement Group can help you sort through the maze of these funds.'
In this article we will discuss:
- 1. Closed-end funds - basics versus open-end funds.
2. The strengths and downsides of investing in closed-end funds.
3. Benefits of closed-end funds for income-seeking retirees in a low interest rate environment.
How Much Does a Closed-End Fund Cost?
Numerous Caterpillar clients of ours ask about closed-end funds. An investment corporation called a closed-end fund pools funds from many different investors and invests them in stocks, bonds, and other securities. A fund generally issues a fixed number of shares and buys securities with the proceeds of an initial public offering (IPO). Its capital structure and number of shares are not yet known; the number of shares is fixed (this is why it is called closed-end). Every investor holds some of these holdings in shares.
Closed-end funds may be a good choice for retirees and pre-retirees who want regular income streams. Closed-end funds typically offer higher yields than traditional mutual funds because they are structured to invest in more assets such as real estate and commodities, according to a report by the Investment Company Institute (ICI) in 2021. Closed-end funds may also provide diversification and appreciation of capital. Retirees and pre-retirees should weigh investment goals and risk tolerance before investing in closed-end funds.
A fund's net asset value is its holdings value divided by the number of outstanding shares. Once it goes public, the fund trades on an exchange or the over-the-counter market just like any other security. A professionally managed closed-end fund can be diversified or non-diversified. Investing in the fund may also earn share price appreciation, dividend income and capital gains distributions if the fund sells individual securities at a profit during the year.
Closed-end funds - established in the nineteenth century - are often compared to mutual funds - more famous although younger - which are less well-known. The Investment Company Act of 1940 defines a closed-end company as 'any management company other than an open-end company' (such as a mutual fund). They are both categories of investment companies regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission but have substantial differences. Caterpillar employees might be curious about the differences and similarities of both types of funds.
Closed-end funds are much older than open-end mutual funds and there are far fewer of them; closed-end funds number in the hundreds, while open-end mutual funds number in the thousands. While a closed-end fund is different from an exchange-traded fund (ETF), there are some similarities our Caterpillar could use understanding. A closed-end fund can invest like an open-end fund. But historically most closed-end funds were bond funds, the largest category being tax-exempt bond funds.
How Is a Closed-End Fund Different From an Open-End Fund?
And like most investment companies, a closed-end fund diversifies by investing in different securities. But we caution our Caterpillar clients that diversification alone cannot deliver a profit or protect against loss. A closed-end fund also provides diversification but also professional management and a consistent investment objective. Like mutual funds, closed-end funds do not collect taxes at the fund level but pass those tax obligations onto shareholders.
The biggest difference between a closed-end and an open-end fund that we want our Caterpillar clients to understand is that while an open-end fund must always be able to redeem your shares directly, most closed-end fund shares are traded on market exchanges and are generally not redeemed directly by the company issuing them. In a closed-end fund, the share count is set at the time of the IPO. Rather, an open-end fund issues and redeems shares daily-hence the name open-end-and the number of shares changes day to day - which affects the fund's net asset value (NAV).
Just like equities, closed-end funds move during the day - and their prices change throughout the day too. That is distinct from an open-end fund whose NAV is calculated only once per day after the markets close. If you want to sell your shares of a closed-end fund, the appetite of other investors to buy them will dictate how easy it is to do so and what price you will get.
Since closed-end funds trade on market exchanges, the market price of a share varies with market supply and demand. If demand exceeds supply, the market price for a closed-end fund's shares may be above its NAV, or net asset value, as the share is intrinsically valued. Demand may outstrip supply and closed-end fund shares may trade below their NAV. Some closed-end fund shares trade at a premium, most trade at a discount. This is not true of open-end funds, which will redeem your shares at NAV on the day you sell (or on the next closing day if you sell after 4 p.m.).
Joan buys 1000 shares of a closed-end mutual fund. She pays USD 14.50 a share. The NAV is USD 15.75. It amounts to Joan getting assets for USD 14,500. Joan sells her stock later for USD 16. She made USD 1,500 ($16,000 - USD 14,500) before transaction fees and commissions. Had she instead bought her shares at USD 16 and sold them at USD 14.50, Joan would have sold her portion of the fund for less than they were worth.
So how Is a Closed-End Fund Different from an Exchange-Traded Fund?
Some Caterpillar clients wonder how closed-end funds differ from exchange-traded funds. Exchange-traded funds are much newer than closed-end funds. A closed-end fund may also technically be an exchange-traded fund. They both trade during the day on main exchanges. But today most ETFs are passively managed. The fund seeks to replicate a given index return as closely as possible. In turn, their market prices closely match the values of the securities in its portfolio, which track the index. Closed-end funds typically trade above or below their NAV.
Interval Funds
A closed-end fund that periodically offers its shareholders the ability to sell back some or all of its shares is called an interval fund. Shareholders notify the fund by a specified date if they want to accept the offer - usually every three to six months or annually - by that date. The actual repurchase will occur at a price determined by the fund's NAV on a specified date, usually shortly after the deadline for notifying the fund of a repurchase decision.
In contrast with many closed-end funds however, an interval fund possesses the characteristics of both closed-end and open-end funds. As with mutual funds, an interval fund might choose to maintain a price tied to the fund's NAV. And unlike many closed-end funds, shares of an interval fund can be priced daily. But because shares are not redeemed daily, the SEC classes them as closed-end funds.
The Strengths of a Closed-End Fund.
Shares in closed-end funds purchased at a discount represent some kind of leverage - the ability to profit both from rising values of the fund's holdings and from rising demand for the shares themselves. This leverage could boost your investment.
Some closed-end funds borrow money at relatively low cost and put it into higher-yielding securities. This can raise a fund's return if interest rates are falling or staying low. However, if interest rates go up or low-cost credit becomes unavailable, leveraged bond funds could underperform other bond funds that use no leverage.
A closed-end fund needs not hold cash for redemptions because it has a fixed number of shares. This capital may be used to try to increase investor returns. Because shareholders do not redeem shares directly, a manager need not sell assets to cover unexpected shareholder redemptions and can instead invest in less liquid securities.
A closed-end fund is not required to accommodate sudden inflows of capital from shareholders like an open-end fund does. Such unexpected inflows may require a fund to buy securities to invest the money - even if the manager thinks the market is expensive already; a closed-end fund manager has no such problem.
The board of directors for a closed-end fund might sometimes decide to convert the fund to an open-end structure. Suppose this happened, investors who bought shares at a discount to the NAV would profit from the difference between their discounted purchase price and the NAV of the new open-end fund.
Because closed-end funds are traded and priced throughout the day instead of just at the end of the business day, you control the price you pay when you sell and the timing of your sales.Closed-end funds have no minimum purchase requirements on the secondary market.It is because closed-end funds are traded on the secondary market; typically they have no marketing expenses like open-end funds do.
Tradeoffs with a Closed-End Fund.
A closed-end fund's market price may fall if investor demand decreases. Demand may decrease if the market perceives the fund or fund manager as bad or other market conditions exist outside of the fund. And the share price may drop despite the fund manager making smart investments and increasing the fund's asset value.
More closed-end funds can invest in illiquid securities than mutual funds - which can be problematic if the fund manager must sell the securities. An illiquid security generally is one that cannot be sold within seven days at the approximate price the fund uses to calculate NAV.
Because leverage magnifies losses as well as increases return, a closed-end fund that uses leverage might underperform an unleveraged fund when its strategy does not work as expected - for instance if interest rates rise or cheap credit contracts become available - as in a credit crisis. Buy-sell agreements could increase losses; if investor demand is down, your shares will drop too.
Even if the fund manager does a good job and the fund's assets appreciate in value, lack of investor demand could cause the fund's market price to drop below your purchase price and the fund's NAV. The fact that they trade at a premium or discount means closed-end funds can be more volatile than their open-end counterparts.If the board of directors issues new shares by way of a rights offering that would dilute the value of the existing shares, the fund can increase its capital.
A closed-end fund is exposed to the same market risks as any fund that invests in stocks or bonds - for instance, the risk that a bond will default, prepay or be called early; a company will go bankrupt; and that interest rates, inflation, credit availability, political or economic conditions, and/or currency risks will affect the fund's holdings.
Closed-end fund performance is less readily available than open-end fund performance. They are sometimes also less liquid.
Featured Video
Articles you may find interesting:
- Corporate Employees: 8 Factors When Choosing a Mutual Fund
- Use of Escrow Accounts: Divorce
- Medicare Open Enrollment for Corporate Employees: Cost Changes in 2024!
- Stages of Retirement for Corporate Employees
- 7 Things to Consider Before Leaving Your Company
- How Are Workers Impacted by Inflation & Rising Interest Rates?
- Lump-Sum vs Annuity and Rising Interest Rates
- Internal Revenue Code Section 409A (Governing Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plans)
- Corporate Employees: Do NOT Believe These 6 Retirement Myths!
- 401K, Social Security, Pension – How to Maximize Your Options
- Have You Looked at Your 401(k) Plan Recently?
- 11 Questions You Should Ask Yourself When Planning for Retirement
- Worst Month of Layoffs In Over a Year!
- Corporate Employees: 8 Factors When Choosing a Mutual Fund
- Use of Escrow Accounts: Divorce
- Medicare Open Enrollment for Corporate Employees: Cost Changes in 2024!
- Stages of Retirement for Corporate Employees
- 7 Things to Consider Before Leaving Your Company
- How Are Workers Impacted by Inflation & Rising Interest Rates?
- Lump-Sum vs Annuity and Rising Interest Rates
- Internal Revenue Code Section 409A (Governing Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plans)
- Corporate Employees: Do NOT Believe These 6 Retirement Myths!
- 401K, Social Security, Pension – How to Maximize Your Options
- Have You Looked at Your 401(k) Plan Recently?
- 11 Questions You Should Ask Yourself When Planning for Retirement
- Worst Month of Layoffs In Over a Year!
You buy a ticket to a limited-time show by investing in closed-end funds. A closed-end fund has a fixed number of shares just like a theater production has fixed seats. Those shares are sold and the show/fund is closed to new investors. Just as a popular play might draw huge crowds for tickets, a successful closed-end fund might draw significant investor interest and potentially better returns. Just as some shows are better than others, you should research and choose a closed-end fund that meets your investment goals and risk tolerance, however.
Added Fact:
A new study from Morningstar published in April 2023 concluded that closed-end funds could be a good fit for income-seeking investors at low interest rates. The study said closed-end funds that focus on high-yield bonds and dividend-paying stocks historically have offered higher yields than open-end mutual funds. This is especially useful for 60-something investors who want regular income streams in retirement. Open-end funds may provide better yields and diversification benefits than traditional retirement investments. (Source: Morningstar, April 2023)
Added Analogy:
Closed-end investing is like joining an elite club with a finite number of memberships. Like the club that gives members special privileges and amenities, closed-end funds offer investors a broad spectrum of investments. Every membership gets a piece of the fund's holdings, with potential gains for investors. As different clubs serve different interests, so too must investors research and select closed-end funds that meet their financial goals and tolerance for risk. Selecting the right 'club' or closed-end fund can provide income generation, potential capital appreciation and diversification for retirees and pre-retirees.
Sources:
1. Reaves Asset Management. 'Retirees: Keep Your Eyes on Income with CEFs.' Reaves Asset Management, https://insights.reavesam.com/blog/retirees-keep-your-eyes-on-income-with-cef?utm_source=chatgpt.com .
2. Investopedia. 'Closed-End vs. Open-End Investments: What's the Difference?' Investopedia, https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042315/what-are-primary-differences-between-closed-end-investment-and-open-end-investment.asp?utm_source=chatgpt.com .
3. InvestmentNews. 'Why Anxious Retirees Should Consider Closed-End Funds.' InvestmentNews, https://www.investmentnews.com/retirement-planning/why-anxious-retirees-should-consider-closed-end-funds/222196?utm_source=chatgpt.com .
4. BlackRock. 'Five Reasons to Consider Closed-End Funds in Your Portfolio.' BlackRock, https://www.blackrock.com/us/individual/education/closed-end-funds/insights/reasons-to-use-closed-end-funds?utm_source=chatgpt.com .
5. Financial Planning. 'Closed-End Funds: From All Angles.' Financial Planning, https://www.financial-planning.com/news/closed-end-funds-from-all-angles?utm_source=chatgpt.com .
How does the transition from the Solar Plan to the Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan impact current or former employees of Caterpillar Inc. in terms of retirement benefits and service credits? Considering both plans' differences, what aspects should employees of Caterpillar Inc. understand to ensure they are maximizing their retirement benefits under this merged structure?
Transition from Solar Plan to Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan: The transition from the Solar Plan to the Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan maintained the benefits of those previously covered under the Solar Plan without impact. Both plans allowed the continuation of prior service credits and the incorporation of benefits payable under previous retirement plans. For current or former employees, understanding the nuances of how prior service credits and benefits are integrated can maximize their retirement benefits under the merged structure.
What specific criteria must Caterpillar Inc. employees meet to qualify for early retirement and what implications does this have on their pension benefits? For employees planning early retirement, what calculations or benefit reductions should they be prepared for according to Caterpillar Inc.’s policies?
Criteria for Early Retirement at Caterpillar Inc.: Employees wishing to take early retirement must meet specific age and service requirements detailed in the plan documents. For early retirement, benefits calculations and potential reductions are significant. Employees need to prepare for possible reductions in their pension benefits depending on their age and years of credited service at retirement.
In the context of the Pension Equity Plan (PEP) and the Traditional Pension Plan, how do the benefit calculations differ for employees at Caterpillar Inc., particularly for those who switched from the Traditional Plan to the PEP? What considerations should current Caterpillar Inc. employees take into account when evaluating which plan may offer them more secure benefits?
Differences Between PEP and Traditional Pension Plan: The benefit calculations for the Pension Equity Plan (PEP) and the Traditional Pension Plan differ significantly. PEP calculates a lump sum based on salary and years of service, while the Traditional Plan calculates benefits based on final earnings or credited service formulas. Employees need to consider which plan offers more secure benefits based on their individual career trajectory and earnings history.
What steps must Caterpillar Inc. employees take to ensure that their Credited Service is accurately calculated and maintained throughout their employment, especially in light of the company's policies regarding breaks in service? How might phases of employment, such as parental leave or temporary positions, affect this calculation?
Credited Service Calculation and Maintenance: To ensure accurate credited service calculation, employees must maintain thorough records and communicate any changes in employment status, such as breaks in service or changes in personal information, to the plan administrator. Understanding the rules for service credits during different phases of employment, such as parental leave or temporary positions, is crucial.
How can employees at Caterpillar Inc. file a claim for benefits under the retirement plans, and what are the essential details they need to provide to ensure their claims are processed smoothly? If they encounter issues or denials, what recourse do they have within the Caterpillar Inc. system to appeal these decisions?
Filing a Claim for Benefits: Employees should provide detailed and accurate information when filing a claim for benefits under the retirement plans. If issues or denials occur, they have the right to appeal these decisions. Familiarity with the claims procedure and required documentation can streamline this process.
For employees approaching retirement, what resources are available through Caterpillar Inc. to help them navigate the complexities of their retirement benefits? What steps should an employee take if they wish to understand their benefits better or need assistance with retirement planning?
Resources for Navigating Retirement Benefits: Caterpillar Inc. offers resources to assist employees in navigating the complexities of their retirement benefits. Employees approaching retirement should utilize these resources and may need to engage with the company's human resources or benefits departments for personalized assistance.
What are the implications of the changes to the cash-out limit for de minimis benefits at Caterpillar Inc., which will take effect after December 31, 2023? How does this change affect employees who may have a vested interest in understanding their financial benefit options upon termination or retirement?
Implications of Cash-Out Limit Changes: The increase in the cash-out limit for de minimis benefits affects how small vested benefits are processed upon termination or retirement. Employees with small benefit amounts should understand how these changes may impact their options and tax implications.
How does Caterpillar Inc. ensure that its pension benefits are protected from creditors, and what specific provisions exist to safeguard these benefits? Moreover, how do legal instruments like Qualified Domestic Relations Orders (QDROs) interact with Caterpillar Inc.'s benefits system for employees undergoing divorce?
Protection of Pension Benefits from Creditors: Caterpillar Inc.'s retirement plans are designed with protections to safeguard benefits from creditors, including adherence to Qualified Domestic Relations Orders (QDROs) during instances like divorce. Employees should understand how these legal instruments can affect their retirement savings.
In what ways does the Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan provide coverage for disability retirement, and how is this benefit calculated for employees? What factors influence eligibility and how do employees initiate claims if they find themselves in need of these benefits?
Disability Retirement Coverage: The plan provides specific provisions for disability retirement, including how benefits are calculated and eligibility criteria. Employees should be aware of how disability affects their benefits and the process for initiating claims if needed.
How can Caterpillar Inc. employees contact the company to learn more about their retirement benefits, and what information should they have ready when making inquiries? Additionally, what specific departments at Caterpillar Inc. should employees reach out to for the most efficient assistance regarding their retirement plan questions?
Contacting the Company for Retirement Benefit Information: Employees can contact the Caterpillar Benefits Center for inquiries about their retirement benefits. Knowing the specific departments to contact for efficient assistance is crucial for addressing concerns and making informed decisions about retirement planning.
-2.png)
.webp)